Views of personal identity
Thinkers
Each thinker has a page of their own: the view, the argument behind it, and where it meets and parts from Parfit.
Each entry is marked by its answer to one question: is a person anything over and above a body, a brain and a stream of experiences? Parfit, the reductionist, says no; the further-fact views say yes. Compare all views side by side →
Before 1900
- The Buddhist no-self viewfrom the fifth century BCReductionist
No self exists apart from the passing aggregates. A chariot is only its parts, arranged.
- John Locke1632–1704Reductionist
A person reaches as far back as their consciousness does. The prince wakes in the cobbler's body and is still the prince.
- Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz1646–1716Further fact
To become the King of China and forget who you were would be no better than to be annihilated.
- Joseph Butler and Thomas Reid1692–1752; 1710–1796Further fact
Identity is simple and indivisible. Memory presupposes it and cannot make it.
- David Hume1711–1776Reductionist
There is no self to be found, only a bundle of perceptions, and our belief in its identity is a fiction.
- Immanuel Kant1724–1804Qualified
The "I think" is a form of thought, not a glimpse of a soul. Consciousness might pass between substances like motion between balls.
Twentieth century
- P. F. Strawson1919–2006Further fact
Persons are a basic kind of thing: the same thing that weighs ten stone is the thing that is thinking of Paris.
- Bernard Williams1929–2003Qualified
Tell a body-swap story one way and you go with your memories. Tell it another and you fear what will happen to your body.
- Sydney Shoemaker1931–2022Reductionist
Brownson has Brown's brain and Robinson's body, and he is Brown. Quasi-memory frees memory from presupposing identity.
- Harry Frankfurt1929–2023Qualified
A person is a creature who can care which of its own desires move it.
- Robert Nozick1938–2002Reductionist
You are your closest continuer, if it is close enough and has no rival. Identity can depend on what else exists.
- David Lewis1941–2001Reductionist
In a fission case there were two persons all along, sharing their early stages. Identity and what matters never come apart.
- Daniel Dennett1942–2024Reductionist
A brain in a vat, a body in the field: where am I? The self is a centre of narrative gravity.
Since Parfit
- Richard Swinburneborn 1934Further fact
A person is a soul joined to a body. Whether a future person is you is always a definite, further fact.
- Eric OlsoncontemporaryReductionist
You are a human animal, and you last as long as that organism lives, whatever happens to your psychology.
- Marya SchechtmancontemporaryQualified
A person makes themselves by understanding their life as a story, and a person life is lived among others.
- Christine Korsgaardborn 1952Qualified
The unity of a person is not found by metaphysics but made by agency: to act at all, I must take myself as one.
- Thomas Metzingerborn 1958Reductionist
Nobody has ever had or been a self. There is only a self-model that the brain does not recognise as a model.
Many worlds and many copies
- Simon Saunders and David WallacecontemporaryReductionist
Lewis's account applied to Everett: branching persons share a present and are genuinely uncertain which future is theirs.
- Sean Carrollborn 1966Reductionist
Just after branching, before you look, you do not know which branch you are in. Probability is self-locating uncertainty.
- Max Tegmarkborn 1967Reductionist
Quantum suicide: in Everett's multiverse the experimenter always survives somewhere. Real deaths are gradual, so expect no immortality.
- Uploads and copiesfrom about 2000Reductionist
Scan a brain and run it on a computer, gradually or all at once, then copy it. Is the upload you?
- David Deutschborn 1953Qualified
A person is a universal explainer. The multiverse holds many instances of each of us. An AGI would be a person.